Secondary School Chair of Governors describes A-Levels as "a national joke"

Girls from Badminton School in Bristol jumping in the air.
The school actually sent this photo out as a PR shot
according to a story in The Guardian

It's A-Level results day today and two things are certain. Photos of pretty female students leaping in the air after getting their results (see the Sexy A-Levels Blog) and right wing journalists claiming the exams get "easier" each year and in particular are a lot easier than when they did them.

These articles all follow the same theme, today Toby Young from the Telegraph wrote a piece describing A-Levels as a "national joke". I got into a bit of an argument with him on Twitter about this which went as follows:

This really seemed to hit a nerve as the next Tweet I got from Toby wasn't very nice:

Owch!! Toby himself shows a remarkable self-insight in his article though:

For those who want to question my motives, you should know that I got two Bs and a C in my A-levels in 1983 (that’s two A*s and an A in today’s money).  So perhaps I’m just bitter and twisted and have a personal stake in doing down the achievements of “the youth”. 

That seems to sum it up and could probably be left there. After all it isn't really news that right wing commentators seem to have a real issue with any suggestion that there might be progress in society and that younger people now might be, well, smarter than they were when they were young.

However Toby Young is now the Chair of Governors of a brand new "Free School" called the West London Free School  In time this school aspires to have a sixth form itself and I think I would have taken a dim view of his comments if I was a student, parent or teacher at the school. In my view the Chair of Governors should be celebrating the success of the school and its students.

Over the past week young people have got a bad press when a few thousand took part in rioting, looting and making silly comments on social networking sites. Today many more tens of thousands of  young people collected results after years of working hard and have been rewarded with places at University.

Shame on Toby Young and all others that rather than celebrating this success seek to undermine it. The only consolation is any self-respecting A-level student is probably too drunk from celebrating or commiserating to notice. But we should all raise a glass tonight to celebrate the hard work and success of the tens of thousands of A-level students! Well done!

Moral Panic takes hold in England

In the aftermath of last week's riots there has understandably been a mood of alarm and a general feeling that "something should be done". In this kind of situation we look to "the Authorities" to sort things out and make us feel safe. In a crisis wise people in authority stay cool, calm and act carefully. After all if a building is on fire you don't run out of it in a mad panic screaming for everyone to follow you straight into the fire because you didn't check where the exit was...

But people in authority in England have not acted wisely. The Police and the Government have got into an unseemly row about who is to "blame". Politicians are trying to use the situation to re-enforce ideas they had previously blaming poverty, cuts, liberalism, bankers, schools, parents, children, the Police, lawless criminals and anyone else who fits into their political world view.

And now the Judiciary, either acting on their own or under the influence of politicians, have started to pass increasingly disproportionate and illogical sentences. Two users of Facebook faced 4 year jail sentences even though one had clearly meant his posts as a silly and irresponsible joke whilst in Bury St Edmunds another person faced a 12 month ban from social networks and a home curfew for more or less the same stupidity on Facebook.

A judge in Manchester blamed the "Facebook generation" for what appeared nothing more than opportunistic theft by two teenage girls of clothes and this is on top of the already widely reported jailing of a person for 6 months for stealing water, the mother of two young children jailed for receiving a pair of shorts as stolen goods and the warning to a person stealing an ice cream cone they may face a jail sentence.

I could go on. A mood of moral panic seems to be gripping the country and rather than leading our leaders are trying to follow the mood for any advantage they can get.  As Gaby Hinsliff said on Twitter:

gabyhinsliff Gaby Hinsliff 

hmm 1. Public demands rioters strung up 2. PM tells courts to string em up 3.Courts do 4. Public horrified by 4 yrs for inciting on Fbook...

gabyhinsliff Gaby Hinsliff 

..& that's roughly why govt shd lead not follow public opinion. We all change our minds overnight & forget we ever thought that. Govts cant.

Today Cameron said of the Facebook "incitement" jailings.

Thanks to @julianswainson for image

julianswainson 

"What happened on our streets was absolutely appalling behaviour and to send a very clear message that it's wrong and won't be tolerated is what the criminal justice system should be doing, They decided in that court to send a tough sentence, send a tough message and I think it's very good that courts are able to do that."

Yes, this is the same Cameron who said of Coulson that "everyone deserves a second chance" and who said of his own behaviour "like many people I did things when I was young that I should not have done an that I regret".

Cameron, Clegg and Boris Johnson rightly got a second chance and they should show some leadership in extending that privilege to the rest of us. They appear to have forgotten that they are in charge and that leadership isn't about re-enforcing panic but keeping calm and carrying on.